Menu & Pricing

Signature Sensibly Sweet Treats = Cookies

Please order at least 7 business days (Monday to Friday & excluding US or NY State Holidays) in advance of the in-person delivery date.  

-Shipping and handling directly will incur an additional fee to cover USPS shipping fees.

Classic Cookie Flavors: $36 per dozen

• S'mores

• Lemon Crinkle

• Chocolate Chip

• Banana Pudding

• Birthday Sprinkle

• Oatmeal

 Premium Cookie Flavors: $45 per dozen

• Chocolate Chip Pecan

• Dark Chocolate Peppermint Crunch

• Oatmeal Cranberry White Chocolate

• Red Velvet

• Brown Butter Chocolate Chip

• Coconut Macadamia

• Stuffed Cookie Butter (Biscoff)

• Strawberry Crunch

• Oatmeal Rum Raisin

GIANT COOKIE CAKE

12 Inch cookie with edible image. 

Please order at least 3 business days (Monday to Friday & excluding US or NY State Holidays) in advance of the in-person delivery date.

• Classic Cookie flavor $85 

• Premium Cookie flavor $100

Catering or Breakfast Treat Platters:

A Pair of Treats Platter (serves a minimum of 10) - $7.95 per serving

Select up to 3 types of treats. Platter Treats available are (mini) muffins, scones, and croissants.

Please order at least 7 business days in advance of the in-person delivery date. Recommend delivery one day before the event.

Muffins flavors-$40 per dozen (standard size)                                        

chocolate chip, banana walnut, apple cinnamon, cornbread muffin, lemon blueberry, pumpkin spice

Scones flavors-$45 per dozen (standard size)

Cinnamon pecan, orange cranberry, chocolate chip, maple walnut, lemon blueberry

Croissants flavors

• Classic Butter -$45 per dozen

• Chocolate Filled -$55 per dozen

Gifting Treats 

Please reach out (phone or email) if you have treat gifting needs that combine any of the below, for example, you are looking to build a treats table for your event, or you need a consultation before ordering your gifting treats.

Thank You Cookies: $25

Sample box of 3 individually wrapped shareable large cookies with a thank you card. 

-Available for pick up at least 3 business days in advance. 

-Shipping and handling directly will incur an additional fee to cover USPS shipping fees.

Messenger Cookies ($100 minimum order):

Individually wrapped (shareable large) cookie with printed message. 

• Classic Cookie flavor-$6/cookie

• Premium Cookie flavor-$7/cookie

Themed (Logo) Cookies (minimum 10 boxes per flavor/$100 minimum order):

Cookies individually boxed with a bow/ribbon and edible logo (company, team, monogram, etc.). Boxes are rigid, clear food-grade packaging & the bow/ribbon is inedible box décor.

-Please order at least 7 business days in advance of the in-person delivery date.

Sensibly sweet sugar cookie- $10/boxed cookie

Classic Cookie flavor-$10/boxed cookie

Premium Cookie flavor -occasional availability, request a quote, price per flavor of boxed cookie will vary

All products are made in a home kitchen registered with the NYS Department of Agriculture & Markets. Certain frostings, fillings, and toppings are not permitted under this registration.